Review of The Dread Wyrm by Miles Cameron


One of my favorite reviews of all time.

Every Day Should Be Tuesday

The Traitor Son Cycle might be the best epic fantasy series ongoing right now. Cameron is known for his historical fiction (published as Christian Cameron), and he is really good at the things you would expect him to be good at. There is a lot of what I’ve seen called “vambrace porn.” Which has a certain negative connotation, but Cameron shows the rich tapestry of medieval life in a way fantasy all too rarely does. The battle scenes—and there are a lot of them, in the series and in this book—are phenomenal—tense, chaotic, and bloody. The character list is long, and those characters are distinct and think like people from a very different time. As the story blooms into an epic, the main characters grow and the minor characters flesh out. And the story takes a distinctly fantastic turn as godlike beings begin to take a more direct hand. Those…

View original post 700 more words

Come to Greece this Fall. With me…



Hello, blog readers.  This is my bi-annual ‘Pen and Sword’ tour blog (see the past one here).  This fall, from November 6th to the 17th, 2017, thirty people will tour Greece and Bulgaria… with me.  (Second prize two weeks… wait…)

This will be our third outing.  Last two times we’ve visited the Peloponnese, and gone to such amazing places as Delphi, Mycenae and Mystra. (Not much to see at Sparta, really).


This years tour will visit Thessaloniki, second city of the Byzantine Empire, and use it as a jumping off point to visit all the newly discovered Macedonian tombs and the superb museum at Vergina.  Thanks to a professional Greek guide (with a PhD in Archaeology, so no, you don’t have to listen to me…) as well as to my friend Giannis Kadaglou, we’ll get ‘behind the scenes’ looks at some amazing artifacts, many of which, I admit, feature in my books. We’ll also visit Byzantine and Frankish sites in the area before heading east into the rising sun, and changing eras.  After a visit to Amphipolis, site a major battle of the Peloponnesian War, we’ll go to Alexandroupolis and visit ancient Greek and Thracian sites and then work our way north to Mesembria in Bulgaria, covering many of the sites of the Green Count’s crusade (it’s the subject of my latest historical novel, called, by no coincidence, ‘The Green Count‘ and out in July.

Facebook post

What are these tours like?  Well, first, they are arranged by a professional tour operator, who just happens to be my friend Aliki Hamosfakidou of Dolfin Hellas.  She is not just a tour operator; she helped facilitate the first reenactment of the Battle of Marathon, and she’s done yeoman service to historical writing over the years. Anyway, we stay in four and five star hotels, and we live well and eat excellent food and drink really good wine. at least in part thanks to our resident wine steward, Jamie Harrison.

In addition to good food and wine, we’ll go out at night, not to ‘tourist places’, but to some tavernas and other excitements.  We go listen to music; I happen to love Greek music, and my friend Giannis plays it, so this is not necessarily what you expect to hear…

We visit museums and historical sites every day, and we travel around in a bus that is more like a land yacht.  I confess that the first year, I thought of the bus as a terrible thing… a tourist bus?  Like a nightmare…

Nope.  It’s a fantastic way to have conversations and discussions or even a nap between sites. And it makes the whole operation flexible; our guides have a habit of saying ‘of course, there is a Frankish castle no one visits up there,’ and then we all shout a bit, and then the bus takes us there.  Give or take half a mile of steep rock.

And then….


There is internationally acclaimed historical archer Chris Verwijmeren of the Netherlands demonstrating how to shoot from behind a hoplite’s shield… he will be our archery demonstrator, and teacher, this year!  And there’s Smaro, who has probably the best ancient Greek women’s impression in the world, and Jevon Garrett and me… in Greek kit…

This year, we’ll take a whole day to have a bunch of skilled reenactors, including me and about 1/3 of the people on the tour, to do demonstrations of everything from weapons to cooking.  You can participate to whatever extent you like, up to and including borrowing kit and getting dressed up and shooting bows and what have you.  (Not required, however.  Be not afraid). We’ll do our demonstrations at an un-restored Byzantine Castle of the mid 14th c. (that is also a location in both Green Count and the newest William Gold, Sword of Justice.  Blatant advertisement there.)

Probably worth noting, if you are a fantasy fan, that Greece, Greek art, and Greek military history provide a lot of background for both of my fantasy series…  the castle in Thrace where we’ll play with weapons is the place from which Gabriel and Michael rescue the Emperor in ‘Fell Sword.’  For example.

Italy and Greece 2014 1380.jpg

But wait, that’s not all… for those that wish, there are swordplay lessons every morning.  This year we’ll do Italian arming sword, with some forays into Greek hoplite fighting with both sword and spear.

Delphi swords.jpg

There’s Mike Brennan and Harriet Richert learning Arming sword, Manciolino style, in the Vale of Delphi in 2014 after an epic night of dancing and…drinking…

At Mesembria, a few of us will kit out as knights and have a small deed of arms in commemoration of the Green Count…


(I admit I reuse this photo as often as I can…)

And finally, we’ll visit Varna, in Bulgaria, and visit a large Medieval reenactment there.  A few of us will participate (you can too, if you want to) and everyone else will get great seats and a good dinner….

The trip starts and ends at Thessaloniki.  You have to get yourself there (not included in the tour price) by 6 November and you depart on 17 November.  The trip is ten full days and costs 1400 Euros all in double occupancy or a little more if you want a room to yourself.  (1755 euros).  At one hundred forty euros a day, all in, with meals (not wine) and hotel, bus, tickets to sites, guide, swordplay, reenacting…

There are about ten slots left.

If you are interested, contact Aliki ASAP at

And contact me on Facebook so I can add you to the FB group.  It’s fun; lots of people come back year after year….

Fantasy and History: Writing Battle



I have been asked many times what the difference is between writing about historical battles and fantasy battles.  I suspect I’m going to disappoint you all; especially anyone who sees either genre as special and unique, and say that to me, they are often very similar.  There are differences; for example, considering the effect of a dragon on a medieval battlefield is virtually the definition of ‘speculative fiction’ and trying to imagine the impact of reliable aviation (as in, a hippogrif, or allied wyverns) on logistics or reconnaissance in a  medieval environment is almost as challenging.

But for me, the writer, both kinds of battle scenes are based on experience.  The experience comes to me in different ways; lived experience, like conducting electronic warfare in an aging S-3 Viking;

Military Career

reenactment experience, like commanding a thousand men (and women) in a recreation of a battle…


Or second hand experience, like reading a period account; perhaps Froissart‘s description of Otterburn or a detailed battlefield analysis by a modern historian, whether from Osprey or from an archaeological site survey.  Sometimes experience mixes them; certainly the deepest study I’ve ever made of a single battle was my study of Plataea in 479 BCE; I walked the battlefield many times in person, but that’s not like having been int he battle; I’ve done a fair amount of reenacting in the 480 BCE period, but that’s till not the same as being there; I’ve read almost every word written on the subject, from Herodotus to modern PhD dissertations…


All the usual suspects make writing about battle especially challenging.  Anyone who watches the History Channel or has seen a documentary on the Second World War or the war in Iraq or even recent fighting against ISIS has to be aware that every survivor of an intense combat experience has a different story of events; sometimes they even have different orders of occurrence, so that what seems to be someones magisterial, factual account of the Battle of Gettysburg may later appear to be heavily edited or rationalized.  I have now read, for example, about forty first hand accounts of the first three days on the Somme; the extremely different levels of artillery preparation and the different German reactions meant that some British units were decimated while others moved briskly, even gloriously, forward to their objectives, giving different men starkly unique points of view about the same battle for the same piece of ground.

Alongside the difficulty of capturing ‘what really happened’ is, to me, the excitement and the problem of capturing ‘why it really happened.’  Battles; that is, the sort of decisive battles beloved of writers like me and wargamers and reenactors, are comparatively rare events.  Despite what many writers would have you believe, a battle is not at all the ‘natural result’ of a military campaign.  To give a few famous examples; after Poitiers, the French went to great lengths to avoid decisive field actions against the English; in the American Revolution, the nascent American army was very cautious in engaging the British field armies after White Plains and Brandywine; almost no one these days wants a stand-up decisive battle with tanks and air deployed against a US/NATO force.  Roman and Byzantine armies marched endlessly around enemy terrain without being offered battle on any number of occasions.  It is virtually a truism in military history that a major battle requires the commanders of both sides to believe that they have a decisive superiority in men, or material, or moral, and one of them is almost inevitably wrong.

And because one of them is wrong, there’s a story there; a story of character, of intellect, or anger or foolishness or vanity; really,a ll the things that go into good character writing.  And, as any gamer knows, armies themselves have character, although not always the colourful and enjoyable character they appear to have when painted in 28mm.  To understand why the french lost at Azincourt, for example, it is essential to understand a lot about French politics, about the mindset of the French chivalry, about…history.

And in a fantasy novel, most of the same rules apply or at least they ought to.  Small, plucky warbands should not try to face giant armies of evil unless there are real, tactical reasons to do so; fleets stay in port when faced with unequal odds unless they have no other choice. Leonidas of Sparta led what is arguably the most famous dire last stand in history for complex political reasons (beautifully captured by Steven Pressfield, in his superb novel ‘Gates of Fire’ and if you have not read it, you should.).  Leonidas did not merely stroll out one day, full of Spartan bravado, and elect to sacrifice himself and his state’s elite regiment for vanity.

Likewise, when Phormio led his outnumbered triremes to victory against Sparta, he did so from necessity, and after doing all the things a good storybook hero does; concentrating on morale, on training, and good pay, on tactical advantage. (Eventually, I hope someone will pay me to write a book about Phormio, one of my heroes.).

Even when more balanced forces clash, the events that lead up to the day of battle are often so utterly determinant of the outcome that they really are more important to the story than the actual moments of conflict; the poem ‘For the want of a nail’ pretty much summarizes my views on military history.  The devil remains in details, whether of study, of experience, or of preparation for the fight.

One of the easiest things to write is battlefield magic in a fantasy setting.  To quote my friend and fellow reenactor and gamer, Stephan Callahan, ‘Battlefield magic is just artillery that walks.’  This is almost exactly true.  In the Red Knight series, I have tried to play with other kinds of battlefield magic; a spell that cuts bowstrings or snaps bows or rusts swords or heats armour…all of those sound effective, but really, given and reasonable matrix of magical ‘reality’ surely as soon as some smart lass comes up with a spell to superheat iron, someone else comes p with a rune to protect the iron; after all, that sort of ‘technological’ give and take seems to appear in every period of military history that we have enough data to study.

I did get a great deal of pleasure out of using my experience in EW (electronic warfare) and ASW (anti-submarine warfare) in writing Plague do Swords.  My experience of carrier landings and my time as an amateur falconer were combined to give what I hope the reader perceives as ‘realistic’ views on flying a hippogriff off a medieval round ship. I tried to imagine how magic, the emanation of magical power and the propagation of such emanations might work int he physical world for detection of distant enemy casters at work, even for targeting.  I believe that the scene in which Morgon Mortirmir helps boil water for laundry and thus draws the enemy sea monsters to a fight is one of the most frequently queried and asked about in all the RK books; what the reader was supposed to catch was that by casting, Mortirmir revealed his position…  I spent time working out how, if a magical wave front moved in water the way sound does, the monsters would detect it, but that’s still roughly based on the real world.  I used to spend a lot of time thinking about sonar… and radar…

Plague oif swords

One last comment.  Years ago, I received a very nice piece of ‘fan mail’ from an Australian SAS veteran.  He said a number of nice things and then went on to say something like ‘…but you must know perfectly well that most of the intimacy of actual combat is in the black and not really possible to remember.’  Right; I admit it; no real warrior or soldier could remember all the details of hand-to-hand combat that readers like to see.  Further to that, there is an artificiality to the notion of military leadership, especially on the battlefield; I could name you examples of times where I suspect a general or leader claimed a brilliant tactic after the event, but at the time, depended utterly on luck and the toughness of his men to get him through the hour. There are a great many things that, even in a small action, no one can ever know.

But I’ll close with my last similarity between the battle genres; they are both fiction.  I don’t mean they are ‘lies.’  I mean that, just as a great character  novel like ‘Middlemarch’ or ‘Wuthering Heights’ uses a fictitious story to speak to some real things, so a good ‘battle’ novel can use fiction to explore what might have happened on a day in hell. Complete with character and motivation and plot.

And, sometimes, dragons.

Learning Armizare, or, where can I do all that cool stuff?


Torneo 2

Most frequently asked question:  Where can I learn to do all that stuff?

If you don’t care about my discourse on how various simulations of pre-modern sword combat work or don’t work, skip down to the bold type.

This blog article will endeavor to provide you with a spectrum of answers.  In the process, I plan to say some things which I view as obvious, but I’m going to guess that others will find them controversial.

So, really, the question I am very frequently asked is ‘Where can I learn to fight like the knight/be a knight/do that reenacting thing you do.’  There’s a corollary question, too; ‘I live 200 kilometers from the nearest city; I live in Iowa; I live in Alberta… how do I learn…’

This question needs to be broken down.  And in this blog, I will give an answer; several answers.  But I want to look at the question.

First, this blog is all about various fighting arts.  If you want to talk reenacting, that’s for another day.  Actually, it may be the next blog, because maybe my third most frequent fan question is ‘where can I join a reenactment group.’



In the picture above, I’m wearing a pretty damn good late 14th c. harness.  So is my opponent.  And we’re in pretty accurate lists; that is, the size and style of the fighting space is period correct; and we’re using steel-headed but rebated spears (lanzia) which is a correct, late fourteenth century chivalric fighting style. Oh, and we’re surrounded by a crowd of 14th c. reenactors watching us. We are also fighting in a period style; the Italian style known as Armizare.  To me, this is pretty close to heaven (this is in Italy, BTW).


This is a very different thing, although it may, at first glance, look similar.  This is two fighters from the ‘Battle of Nations’ part of the continuum of martial sport.  At first glance they look medieval, although a little examination will show that almost all their equipment is stylized and sporterized.  (Look, for example, at the American’s sword and the size of the shields.  I could go on.).  But leaving equipment aside, the BOTNs style of combat forbids thrusting… the single most important aspect of foot combat in the later Middle Ages.  No ‘cut’ with a single sword would even be noticeable to a fully armoured knight, so the entire exchange becomes ‘tag with swords’ that completely benefits really big, fast men, and where technique, especially the techniques we know real knights used, simply don’t work.  No spears, no pikes, not thrusting points, no long sword. Do I sound shrill?  Perhaps I’m just tired of having this held up to me as an example of medieval fighting.  It is not, and in fact, it reinforces the trope I have to fight every day as an author; that knights were unskilled barbarians hacking at each other in a blood-frenzy.

And don’t even get me started on the whole inclusion of pre-1945 nationalism and the lack of chivalry.

Let’s move on.


These are two (randomly chosen) folks with long swords at a modern HEMA (Historical European Martial Arts) tournament. (I will not, for the moment, digress on how much I dislike this term)  They wear armour of textile and plastic, and sometimes their swords are plastic or nylon. They wear entirely modern fencing equipment, fence or fight in modern sports facilities, and are watched by modern crowds. On the other hand, many (most?) of them practice hard to use at least some of the techniques taught by Medieval, Renaissance, and Baroque authors.  They also include cross-cultural techniques (most of them) and some modern fencing techniques.


This is modern Olympic fencing.  These two fencers are fencing with epees, or the weapon vaguely based on a late 19th c. dueling weapon version of a martial art that is entirely a sport.  Note, for example, how BOTH of them have hit, without making a parry or cover or block or what have you.  I’ll keep the rest of my comments to myself.


This is Kendo, a traditional Japanese martial art. Kendo is not as old as the Samurai tradition and many aspects of it are highly stylized, like Battle of Nations; are sporterized, like HEMA, and simplified so that training can be rigorous, as in modern Olympic fencing.  Kendo can tell us a great deal about the various directions in which modern recreations of Medieval ‘European’ combat may go.

Note.  For me, Armizare is the ‘best’ of these and ‘Battle of Nations’ the ‘worst.’  But I’ve done, and enjoyed all of them.  Armizare is very expensive; Battle of Nations has all by itself, created a massive infrastructure of armourers and kit bashers and puts together huge, really dramatic medieval events that are excellent.  NO ONE IS WRONG.  I love Kendo; I love Olympic style fencing; I love just crossing long swords with a friend in minimal equipment (although when you pile on the modern plastic armour I admit I loose interest).

So, when a person asks me ‘How do I learn to fence?’ that’s a very different question from ‘where do I learn to fight like a knight?’  The whole art of chivalric fighting, from wrestling to jousting, was called, in Medieval Italy, ‘Armizare.’  The rest of this article is mostly concerned with learning Armizare.  We will, for the sake of clarity, call the middle pastime, ‘HEMA’ and the lower pastime ‘Fencing.’ Kendo is a thing all its own and not for today.

All of these are merely locations on a contiuum.

More clarification.  When I say they are locations on a continuum, that’s because it’s important for prospective students to know that ALL martial arts, bar none, whether Krav Maga or Tae Kwan Do or Iado or Armizare are simulations of combat.  MMA is still a simulation.  It can be ‘real’ inside the ring, but the ring itself is a limiting factor.  Training is full of limiting factors, not least of which (I hope) is that you don’t want to injure your training partners.

Also, as I keep saying here and elsewhere, all martial arts and even war itself are cultural artifacts.  Fiji Islanders make war differently from 2016 US Marines, and they, in turn, make war differently from both Macedonian phalangites or French medieval knights.  We tend to believe that’s because of technology; sure, maybe, but even the slightest acquaintance with either the American Revolution or the recent conflict in Afghanistan will show cultural ways of war that leave the contestants unable to communicate even about victory and defeat.  So a Medieval Italian has more needs than the ‘mere’ defeat of an adversary…if he fights in public, he needs to demonstrate a whole lot of manly virtues in his contest, and there are elements to a public fight that, to an outside observer, might look more cooperative than competitive.  This will be different from a marital art practiced in China or a modern MMA match or a brutal street fight with thugs in St. Petersburg or L.A..  Right?

Have I beat this horse to death?

Right.  Back to the nice young and middle-aged people asking to learn to fence. Or fight like knights.  All that was prologue.  I felt it needed to be said because SO MANY people ask me.

So, you want to learn to practice Armizare?

Here’s my advice.  If you live in a city or town with martial arts instruction, start with that.  If someone teaches Italian medieval martial arts, I recommend you check into their credentials and then JOIN.  (You can always ask me if something seems odd, but while there is snake oil in Amizare, there are also many GREAT clubs and instructors.)  I will recommend, here, and often, the International Armizare Society as a resource.  But if no one teaches Italian, there are many who teach the various German systems.  Often, very often, this means a later system that is more like fencing and less like armoured combat.  Some clubs use federschwerts and plastic armour; some use heavier swords.  All part of the continuum.  Nothing you learn there will be a waste of time.

Then there may be no club or school teaching any Medieval fighting arts.  To me, that’s not so bad.  ANY INSTRUCTION in ANY MARTIAL ART will move you closer to understanding fighting in armour and being able to do it.  Karate, Tae Kwan Do, Aikido, Jiu Jitsu, Kendo, Iado, just to name a few ‘Eastern’ martial arts, all teach completely valid skills; footwork, balance, unarmed strikes and grapples.  Strikes and grapples and locks and throws are all part of fighting in armour; they are neither more nor less important than how you use your sword or lance or dagger or pole axe.

In fact, as is brilliantly brought out in ‘Old School‘ by Ellis Amdur, the older Japanese traditions contained almost exactly the same material that the older, more military western traditions contained; nasty, ruthless moves for a quick kill on the battlefield or in a duel, with your thumb or with a dagger or with a big sword.  And while no one Japanese art fully encapsulates all of the samurai tradition (read the book) all of the surviving arts have important pieces.

And while we’re at it, the base of all good western swordsmanship remains Classic French foil.  Yep, so says I.  Foil is the classical ballet of the sword world, and those who play it, even for a year or so, will almost always dominate those who don’t. Because of all the fascinating little lessons it teaches.  So if you can find a basic ‘fencing’ class, I’d say start there.  Fencing and Aikido or jiu-jitsu?  Fantastic.

But… what if there isn’t even a Tae Kwan Do school in your town?  or, you did foil and played with Tae Kwan Do and now…

On to Armizare.

Well.  Here we go.

Buy some books and teach yourself.

Now, up until now, a certain number of my fellow Armizare instructors were no doubt nodding along, but I suspect this is too much heresy.  And yet, let’s face it; almost no knights in the Middle Ages had access to the great Italian or German masters.  Most of them learned from an illiterate master at arms in a castle courtyard.  You, my dear reader, have an incredible array of learning tools that didn’t even exist a decade ago.  While I will concur with most that distance learning is not as good as learning from an actual passionate, talented human being…

….It’s not impossible!

So here’s my recommended course of action for those who want to learn Armizare and live hundreds of miles from the nearest dojo or salle.

  1. Join the IAS above.  It’ll save you time later.  Register, sign in, and state quite clearly on the forums that you are self-teaching.  And, as you are self-teaching, never hesitate to admit when you don’t know something.  I teach this stuff and there’s tons I don’t know.  Never, ever hesitate.  Your admission of ignorance is actually the only chance you have to learn…
  2. Buy a copy of Guy Windsor’s book ‘The Swordsman’s Companion‘ or his more recent ‘Mastering the Art of Arms Vol.II the Long Sword.’  I prefer the former, maybe because it was MY first book on the art.  The art has moved on, some say.  Ya di da.  It’s full of brilliant solo exercises, and if you learn them, you will grow into a decent swordsperson. Period.
  3. Find a pell.  What is a pell?  Mine is a wooden electric utility pole in my back alley.  Some people have the luxury of having a real pell; a log sunk into the ground.  Some use a rubber tire suspended from a rope.  Some use the corner of a house.  I don’t recommend that last. Basically, a pell is something you hit to practice.
  4. Get a sword.  To me, you should start with a steel sword, but heck, friends, you can start with a broom handle, and if all you can afford is a wooden waster, more power to you.  I do not recommend a feder as they are really for a late 16th c. sport and not for armizare, but this, too, is in the continuum; if that’s what you can get and can afford, get a feder.  At the top of the pile, the best in North America, would like a sword that accurately depicts the weight and feel of a medieval long sword. I recommend the Albion or the Arms and Armor products, but if you live in Europe you have access to Pavel Moc and a spectrum of other suppliers.

Now you should be set to train for the next couple of years.  You don’t need a helmet, a gambeson, or gauntlets because, frankly, you should not be crossing swords with another living human being for some time.

Start with exercises.  Both Guy’s book and the IAS videos (available online for members) have simple exercises of footwork and simple blade work.  You should practice every day.  10 minutes a day, 5 days a week is much better than an hour a week, especially as you learn footwork and various guard postures.

And cuts and thrusts.  Once you have a little footwork and some postures from the books/videos, you go out to the pell and start hitting it.  For this, a good wooden waster is pretty ideal.  You don’t have to hit it hard.  Just hit it a lot.  About ten thousand cuts later, you will have a set of good, fast cuts.  I truly recommend learning to cut from ‘The Swordsman’s Companion’ or from Sean Hayes’ video on the IAS website, but here’s the amazing thing; if you just cut at that pell 10,000 times, unless you have severe issues in your stance, you will in fact develop a good cut.  Merely be honest with yourself about speed and strength and posture and watch the videos from time to time, because as you learn more, you will see more, too.

Oh, and poke at the pell.  Thrusts are actually the signature of Late Medieval fighting; slashes won’t really do much to a man in armour. (This is why, in the continuum of simulations, I don’t love the Battle of Nations and their various rivals.  No thrusts, no grappling… not period.  It’s a different thing.  Someone calls it MMA with swords… which I think might be…advertising…)

Right.  5) Practice.

5) Practice.

5) Practice.  In fact, even if you find some classes, remember that classes are only to teach you things; you need to practice them to learn.

6) Oversight.  So, if you are going to be a ‘distance learner’ and learn on your own, I strongly recommend you develop a relationship with the nearest, best Armizare club.  Shop around; you have time, because you are practicing on your own.  But find someone you like even if you will only see them twice a year, in Warsaw or in London or in Chicago.  Make the time and spend the money to go, even once a year; ACCEPT CRITICISM.  You will teach yourself things incorrectly.  It’s part of learning.  Listen to what is said, concentrate hard, and go back to your pell with new understanding.

7) Equipment.  Hey, all that armour and cool medieval clothing looks fantastic!  But… it actually takes a year or two to even know what you want.  DO NOT BUY ARMOUR until you have played with some from other people.  I strongly recommend that no one should buy armour until they have spent a year of two as a squire, helping another armoured fighter in and out; learning about styles and makers.  A good harness is never less than $2000.  It will cost much more if you buy the wrong helmet and the wrong gauntlets.  You can buy armour that hurts you; armour that changes your fighting style for the worse…. much of the armour made today is too bulky, too heavy, and intended to be worn with massive amounts of padding, for various reasons, none of which are authenticity or even safety.  Take your time. learn the art.  You won’t be safe and capable for a year or two, anyway.  And finding a knight or senior man or woman at arms to whom to be a squire is a tried and true method of having both a mentor and an equipment tutor.  And knights need the help.  Really.

8) Recruit.  It is really much easier for 2 people to learn the art than one; with two, you can try things out; my observation is also that with two people to snark at each other, the odds of getting something completely wrong go down somewhat.  And eventually (not right away) you want to do pairs drills; later, with helmets and gauntlets, light sparring; later still, real sparring.  Takes two.  The Pell doesn’t hit back.

And finally 9) which we might also call 0).  Youtube.  There are, literally, thousands of people on youtube telling you how to fight, how to use a sword, and how to wear armour.  Most of them know about as much as you, the novice, know right now.  There seems to be some sort of compulsion for novices to post youtube pieces.  In a way, that’s fantastic; the passion demonstrated is awe inspiring.  But the bad footwork, false times, and sloppy blade and point control are not as impressive.  Be WARY of video.  Different maestros out there have different interpretations of issues in historical martial arts and that’s fine.  Really.  But some videos show, pure drivel that won’t work in your back yard or the salle floor or the lists or anywhere but in the mind of that guy (or girl) and you really need to learn to discriminate…

One more thing… YOU CAN DO THIS.  That’s not some random pat on the head from a life coach.  In two years, with about $4000.00 and some serious work (between 10 minutes and an hour a day, plus some just plain exercise later on) you can come face me in the lists.  You might even beat me; I’m old.  But the thing is in Armizare, the honour is in the doing.  Come and do it!

By now, I have no doubt created a disturbance in the force.  Feel free to ask my questions;  I’ll try and answer them, especially if you ask them on my FB author page.

Calligraphy and authenticity, or Writing about Writing


So here we are, a couple of days from the launch of Plague of Swords, and you’d probably expect me to blog about writing either Plague of Swords or Fall of Dragons.  But, dear reader, I like to surprise; I also think that many of you like to have a little window on the life of a writer.

So here goes. My next series, at least for fantasy, is called Masters and Mages.  (In my head, it’s just called ‘Mastery’ but there you go).  Some of the content of book one, (The Master) has wandered around the net; I tried some of it as freeware, and then I sold it to the nice folks at Gollancz.  It’s a completely different world; there’s neither a Christianity nor an analog thereof; I made up all the religions; and it has a new magic system (actually a number of different magic systems.).  There is a lot of swordplay; but this time, there will be analog Chinese and Japanese and Persian and Turkish swordplay to go alongside the analog Italian and German and English.

You will find similarities…after all, this is still me…

Now, you might ask, what on earth does this have to do with calligraphy?

Well, about four months ago, I started to be fascinated by medieval books of hours (who isn’t, really).  I wasn’t just fascinated by the awesome penmanship and the glorious illustrations.


I was fascinated by the amount of effort; the very practice of all these arts together, just to make a book, and how precious that book must have been.  Paper appears, commercially, in Europe in about 1300 (give or take) and even after it appears, was still ‘lesser’ to vellum, which is sheep (or goat) and the very devil to prepare.  Of course, well prepared vellum is pretty much eternal; unlike, say, the terabyte hard drive holding my daughter’s entire youth in pictures and which will decay to uselessness in another 5 years.  Or like most of the books I own, on acidic paper… but I digress.

The more I examined pre-modern books, the more I decided that I needed to make one, to understand the process; I needed to learn some basic calligraphy. (If you want to understand how to make a medieval book, start here.) Hey, it’s not all sword fighting; I like to dance and cook, too.  So, with help from friends, I got some equipment, and I started on Gothic Quadrata, a scholarly hand of the fourteenth century.


It’s really fun.

Who even knew?  I’ve got about twenty days in this little micro-passion so far, and I now own pens and papers and I’m delighted and amazed at the excellent advice I’ve received on facebook (and a formal thanks to Jason Daub, Jiliyan Milne, David Harden and Cliff Mullin.  Also a sort of delighted puzzlement at how many of my friends already do this… why didn’t anyone tell me?)


The above is riddled with errors.  But it also marks the beginning of the project; I’m writing a whole book of hours.  These will be the back pages; I figure that when I get to the front folios, I’ll be much better at the calligraphy and the illumination. I plan to ask my friend the artist Aurora Simmons to give me a couple of actual miniature paintings (the annunciation of the Virgin is a standard; maybe a Crucifixion, or maybe a Saint Michael).


This is, after all, my favorite medieval illustration of all time; the very model for the Red Knight… the deep inspiration… Also, for the harness I wear when I fight.  Also for a certain amount of contemplation.

And the more time I spend on this, the better I get.  No surprise there. ‘Practice’ is pretty much my battle cry.


This is my latest effort.  I admit, I’m quite proud of it, although I can see many errors; my ‘t’s are weak and my ‘m’s and ‘n’s are still not even and I do tend to cramp my hand.

All true. But here’s the point about ‘The Master.’  In just twenty days of doing this calligraphy, I’ve learned an incredible wealth of detail about being a scholar in the pre-modern world.  My young hero/protagonist is going to university, where, I freely confess, he’s more interested in girls and swords than in his studies. But calligraphy has given me some insight into the issues facing a scholar, even in a magical alternative reality; a world in which, to own a book and study it, as a poor student, you pretty much need to copy it out yourself; how the process of copying can educate you; how fatiguing it might be; how working in a tannery could give you a leg up as a writer (cheaper vellum) and make you smell all day of dog shit (oh, yeah).

My new world isn’t in the late fourteenth century of ours; it’s even more complex, and there may, just may, be an airship or two, and the technology is a little more like the late sixteenth century in some places.  But one thing no one has yet is the printing press.  Scholars copy books.

And now I know a lot more about that experience.  At least the western experience; and I will be reading about Chinese and Japanese calligraphy in coming weeks, while I write the last pages of ‘Fall of Dragons’ and bid goodbye to the world of Alba and the Red Knight.  that is the reality of being a working writer; you have to look ahead, research ahead, and read about one thing (and be passionate about it!) while writing about another.

Wish me luck.